What Happens When Your 203(k) Contractor’s Bid Comes Back Too High

You found the house. You found a contractor. Then the bid shows up and it is thousands of dollars over the number you were planning around. That is one of the most common moments on a 203(k) file, and it feels worse than it usually is. A high bid is a problem to work through, not a dead deal. Here is how I look at it and what your options are.

Why the Bid Gets Measured Against Something

On a Standard 203(k), I prepare the Work Write-Up and Cost Estimate. HUD requires that I prepare it on my own, without using the contractor’s estimate. That is on purpose. The whole point is to have an unbiased number for the work, so nobody is pricing the job off a figure the contractor handed them.

HUD also requires that my Cost Estimate list every Work Item, separate the labor from the materials, and use costs that are reasonable for the area where the house sits. Lump sum pricing is allowed only where a lump sum is normal for that kind of work.

So when your contractor’s bid comes in, there is already a detailed, line-by-line number to hold it up against. That is what makes a high bid something we can actually sort out.

Why It Has to Be Settled Before Closing

This is the part people do not expect. Before closing, your lender has to get a written agreement between you and your contractor. In it, the contractor agrees in writing to complete the work for the amount of the Cost Estimate and within the allotted time frame.

That means a gap between the bid and the estimate cannot just be left open and figured out later. Somebody has to close it before the loan closes. Your lender may also have its own rules on how a difference gets handled, so ask them early rather than late.

What I Check When a Bid Runs High

I have been a Licensed Builder in Michigan since 1994, so I have priced this kind of work from the contractor’s side of the table too. When a bid comes back high, I go through it line by line. These are the things I see most often:

  • Scope that does not match. The bid includes work that is not in the Work Write-Up, or upgrades the materials. A better tile is fine, but it has to be on paper as your choice.
  • Lump sums hiding the details. One big number for “kitchen” or “bathroom” tells nobody anything. Once it is broken into labor and materials, the problem item usually jumps out.
  • Unit costs out of line. A price per square foot or per fixture that is well above what that work goes for in your area.
  • Padding for the unknown. Some contractors build a cushion into every line because they have never worked a renovation loan and are nervous about getting paid. Explaining how the draw process works often brings that number down.
  • Missed items on my side. I check my own numbers too. If the contractor caught something real that my estimate missed, I say so. Being honest about that protects you more than defending a number.

Your Options When the Numbers Don’t Line Up

Here is where I lay out the pros and cons. I do not make this call for you. It is your house and your money, so you decide.

  • Ask the contractor to revise the bid. Bring them the line items that are out of step. A good contractor will walk through them with you, and a lot of high bids get fixed right here.
  • Get another bid. You pick your own contractor. A second bid on the same Work Write-Up tells you quickly whether the first one was high or the market is just tight.
  • Trim the wish list. The Work Write-Up has to identify each item as required to meet HUD’s property standards, a structural change, or a borrower elective. Required repairs stay. Electives are where you have room to cut or phase things out.
  • Talk to your lender about the money side. Whether you can cover a difference out of pocket, or whether the loan amount can move, is a lender question. Get the answer from them in writing.

What I would not do is sign a contract you do not believe in and plan to “fix it with change orders later.” After closing, a change order goes through me on form HUD-92577 with the labor and material costs, and the work cannot proceed until the lender approves it. That is a tool for real surprises behind the walls, not a way to rescue a bad bid.

On a Limited 203(k)

A Limited 203(k) works a little differently. There is usually no consultant write-up, and the lender works from the contractor’s own itemized estimate. That puts more of the weight on you to make sure the bid is fair before it goes in. If you want a second set of eyes on a Limited bid, call me and we can talk through it.

The Bottom Line

A high bid is information. Most of the time it points to a scope mismatch, a lump sum that needs breaking down, or a contractor who is nervous about the process. Keep it straight to the point, put the numbers side by side, and the gap usually closes. My job is to keep you informed and protect you through it, so the project still makes sense and stays within budget on the way to closing. You can also read what your contractor must turn in before closing.

Michigan Inspection Services works 203(k) files across Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. Michael Al has been a Licensed Builder in the State of Michigan since 1994 and a HUD-Approved 203(k) Consultant since 2019, under HUD ID P1984.

Bid Came In Higher Than You Expected?

Send it over before you sign. We will walk through it line by line on a free 30-minute call.

Call: 248-469-8460

Email: mal@mis203k.com

Schedule a Free Call

Scroll to Top